The future of St. Luke's Hospital

|
(8)
The vision of a new CPMC-owned St. Luke's that may never happen

The CPMC hospital-rebuild deal is on life support -- and some say, to use the harsh medical code, it's CTD. Stands for Circling the Drain.

IF the arrogant leadership at CPMC and Sutter Health comes back in two weeks with a radically improved plan, and IF community groups get behind it, and IF the supervisors can trust Sutter enought to even consider it, then there's a chance this creature can be electroshocked back into the land of the living. But that's a lot of ifs. It's entirely possible at this point that the city and CPMC are so far away from agreement that the billion-dollar proposal for a fancy spankin new hospital on Van Ness will never happen.

We're all hopeful. As Emily Lee, an organizer with the Chinese Progressive Association, put it, "we're hearing a very different tone than they took before." CPMC is in something of a bind: Its existing main hospital on California St. doesn't meet state seismic standards, and has to be replaced or upgraded by 2015. And this isn't a typical business that can just pack up and move out of the city -- CPMC would lose far too many patients and too much money. So the crew there has to do business with San Francisco.

But it also has leverage over the city. Everyone in San Francisco agrees that St. Luke's Hospital in the Mission is a critical part of the city's health-care infrastucture. Everyone agrees that it has to remain open as a full-service hospital with emergency and acute-care facilities. And everyone agrees that it also has to be rebuilt (at a cost of about $250 million) and that it loses money every year.

Oh, and CPMC owns it. And threatens to close it down if the city won't move on the Van Ness palace.

 So Sup. David Campos has authored a resolution calling on city officials to start looking into Plan B: What do we do to save St. Luke's if CPMC won't put up the money to rebuild and operate it?

It's a tough question. CPMC, owned by Sutter Health, is a private nonprofit. The city could, in theory, seize the facility under eminent domain, and float a bond to pay for the rebuild and come up with $25 million a year in General Fund money to cover its operating loses, but that seems a stretch, particularly since the taxpayers have already approved a much bigger bond to rebuild SF General.

There are other health-care providers in the city, though -- and some argue that St. Luke's is only a money-loser because CPMC keeps shrinking its operations. "It's become too small to survive without a subsidy," Chuck Idelson, from the California Nurses Association, told me. And in theory, Dignity Health or even Kaiser could decide it was worth the investment to assume operations, particularly if the city joined in some sort of partnership to help. UCSF runs a big ol' hospital on Parnassus Heights, and already helps staff SF General with attending physicians and residents; maybe St. Luke's could be integrated into the university's medical training program.

"We need to explore what it would be like if St. Luke's was operated by someone who cared about the hospital for itself," Lee said. Unlike CPMC, which seems to care about it largely as a bargaining chip.

Joanne Jung, also with CNA, told me that "there has to be a St. Luke's. It's just too important to the city." And if CPMC doesn't want to keep it going, "clearly there has to be another operator., someone who has some decency and respect for the community St. Luke's serves."

Of course, nobody can force CPMC to sell the hospital or give it to another (competing) provider (although I suspect CPMC would be glad to get rid of it) -- and nobody can force Dignity or Kaiser to take it on.

The wildest idea I've heard is for the city to use bond money for the rebuild -- then let the health-care unions run it. A hospital run by hospital workers. Hospitals used to be run by doctors. But Idelson says CNA doesn't have anywhere near the kind of money that would be needed to upgrade and expand services -- and managing a hospital is a huge undertaking.

Chinese Hospital has its own nonprofit; maybe one gets created for St. Luke's.

But something has to happen, and we have to start thinking about it now. Otherwise, CPMC can continue to hold the city hostage.

 

 

Comments

Seriously- there is a huge hospital complex not far away af SFGH. The new CPMC campus at Van Ness would be less than 3 miles away, plus UCSF, Kaiser, and St. Francis, not to mention Seton hospital just over the border in Daly City. If the operations there are shrinking, it sounds like the City can do ok without it. Is there a study that shows the City HAS to have this hospital open and serving patients?

Perhaps it doesn't need to have an ER. Again with all the ERs all over the City, do we need this one that is losing money? In a way, if it is losing them money, can't blame CPMC for wanting to shut it down.

Posted by D.native on Jul. 19, 2012 @ 2:54 pm

too expensive to run, and too near SFGH. If the city were running it, they would have closed it down and moved stuff to SFGH.

If I were CPMC, I'd close down both hospitals and open in Brisbane with shuttle buses. Then the city would be throwing money at them instead of whining.

Posted by Guest on Jul. 19, 2012 @ 11:02 pm

"Big ol'" "fancy, spankin'"

Posted by Troll II on Jul. 19, 2012 @ 2:55 pm

It makes me beyond happy to see SF lose the biggest improvement to its healthcare in decades. It makes me beyond happy to see a gigantic boarded up hotel sit empty on van ness as a monument to our complete inability to allow anything to change anywhere ever. Eff the rich people, their luxury health care and their soul sucking tall buildings

Posted by Bob on Jul. 19, 2012 @ 5:22 pm

Every expert that’s analyzed the finances agrees that St Luke’s will have huge operating losses into the foreseeable future - unless it forsakes the low-income patient base in the neighborhoods which surround it – the Mission, the Excelsior, Bay View Hunter's Point etc., but then it wouldn’t serve its purpose to the community. Even if it captured the private patients in Noe Valley/Bernal Heights, that wouldn’t offset the tremendous amount of indigent and Medi-Cal patients it cares for. So, we’re talking about $300 million to rebuild it at 80 beds, and $25 million in continual annual losses. BUILDING IT AND OPERATING IT FOR 20 YEARS COMES CLOSE TO 1 BILLION DOLLARS. No one is going to take that on… not Dignity Health Care (St Mary’s and St Francis), who made it clear last week they are not interested, not Kaiser, and not SFGH/UCSF and the city.
There is no viable Plan B for St Luke’s, and those closest to the situation - St Luke’s physicians and patients - know it. That’s why you see St Luke’s Chief of Staff, Dr. Kersh, on the steps of City Hall repeatedly pleading with the supervisors and mayor to not let this deal with CPMC slip away.

Posted by Guest Sam on Jul. 20, 2012 @ 7:55 am

Because, among other things, SF General is so overburdened that it can't handle all the ER patients, including critical patients, that it gets, so they get diverted to St. Luke's.

Many of the people who use St. Luke's don't own cars. General is too crowded to take care of them, and taking Muni three miles when you're sick is not always a functional (or even a good) idea.

Posted by tim on Jul. 20, 2012 @ 9:47 am

Europe will tell you. If we had ten St. Luke's, they'd all be overwhelmed and you'd argue we need more. And anyway, who will pay for it? The city is already heading for bankruptcy without taking on the open-ended committment to give unlimited free healtcare to anyone and everyone.

The CPMC deal is the best we can get and, if they pull out, you're going to see what a real healthcare crisis looks like. They can build wherever they want.

Posted by Guest on Jul. 20, 2012 @ 10:36 am

Do you want to get more comfortable with producing maintenance to your home? Probably you'd like to save money or else you have some certain alterations in mind that you just don't rely on to anybody else. What ever your enthusiasm to take issues in your individual palms, here are several redesigning ideas that will make your own home inprovements simpler.

Truth be told, shuttering your closets is surely an superb strategy to reduce your energy charges. This project could be practically free when you know how to use raw components. Shuttering the closets decreases your sq footage and also the workload for the radiators. Even better, your guests won't see any cabinet clutter.

If you have a leak that you simply can't track down, make sure to closed your water off in the neighborhood. Most people are acquainted with the water shutoff valves under the basin, if your drip is below that valve, turning it well won't help you. By transforming this type of water away from with the streets, you will certainly be certain the drip ceases while you are repairing it.

When you initially find out leaks in your roof, it is probably time for any new roofing. Allowing it to go might lead to terrible consequences. Look for a trustworthy roof structure consultant in your town and make them appear check out the roof. Make sure the specialist is competent and experienced.

Living at home that had been created well before 1990, look at having your attic re-insulated with newer supplies as well as protecting foam. Modern property insulating material technology could help you save several hundred dollars in just each year by enhancing the total performance of the heating and air conditioning solutions.

Cleaning generally needs to be in your thoughts whilst creating home improvements. Getting rubbish in the manner will probably gradual you downward enormously. Generally have a trashcan or dumpster setup to enable you to remove the particles as you're operating. This makes your time and energy go a lot better,in addition to being, clean and successful.

Ensure that you along with your professional are on a single site regarding your budget for the task. Tell the truth with the contractor relating to the money you have to commit, don't cover up the wiggle place which you built into the cost. Many homeowners anxiety that they can get undertaken benefit from, but should you be not sincere, you might find oneself getting received second-rate resources or skillfullness as the contractor was looking to lower the price to fit your budget.

Take into account putting in eavestrough includes to hold results in and also other guck away from your drinking water water flow program, preventing harm and floods. An incredible product or service accredited by Mike Holmes is Clever Display Gutter Protection, which matches over current eavestroughs so that you don't need to pay to get all of your drainage program substituted.

If you're considering home improvement, an effective place to begin is simply by tinkering with colour systems. You can do this by obtaining swatches out of your local color retail store, or employing various on the internet coloration system internet sites and apps. Carrying out this is often creative and exciting, and inspire you to come up with ideas you may not have experienced if you had focused entirely on details like furnishings right away.

Prior to getting started on any project, you should initially determine what you're getting into. Starting a project without knowing every little thing can result in one half-done pair of kitchen cabinets and granite tiles without having grout from the seams. Check out the venture initially and work up a model before you begin upon it.

An extremely easy method to enhance your house is to alter out your oxygen filters. Not only do allergens and dust creep in your atmosphere ductwork once the filter is simply too blocked, however the productivity of your process can be brought down by disregarding to improve the filters. This is essential to do usually in case you have domestic pets in the home.

Even though your kitchen flooring looks degree towards the human eye, be sure you work with a levels when setting up cabinets. Start off through the greatest point in your kitchen area flooring and set a standard line all over the length of the wall how the units is going to be mounted to make certain that your surfaces will be stage once installed.

Rearranging your furniture could be enjoyable, but frequently you require visible aides to figure out where to place every little thing. A great way to prepare furnishings with graphic aiding is as simple as taking a sheet of graph document and removing sq . forms inside a scaled format to stand for your distinct furniture pieces. It is simple to throw your graph papers pieces all around and decide how almost everything can suit together. It definitely will save you the problem of driving your home furniture all around initially.

Never ever try and do electric or pipes function your self regardless how simple the task may appear. Engage a professional to complete the job, and make certain that they have all of the correct permits that the condition demands. In the event you don't authenticate that you may possibly get a badly carried out task with out recourse.

You may make really nice one of a kind vegetation stands from outdated feces. You could buy some outdated feces from lawn income, garage sales or even your neighborhood thrift store. The older the higher as well as the far more unique your grow stand up will probably be. Weathered feces that you apply as being a vegetation stay can add a bit of exclusive nation to your home decoration.

Employ a competent service provider. If you opt to employ someone to complete your own home improvements for you, make sure they are skilled. Check with the town to be sure that the professional is accredited and bonded, inquire about referrals. Most reputable installers will also have a profile of their past job. Get a composed estimate and estimated timeline for completing the position.

The following tips will assist empower you to definitely do your own personal fixes, swap what requires changing, or upgrade any area inside your home, in the event you so pick. Getting an awesome house doesn't have to be anything you leave to other individuals, and by following tips like these, you'll find more competent plus more capable at producing all of the home improvements you desire making.

pozycjonowanie lodz
pozycjonowanie lodz
pozycjonowanie lodz
pozycjonowanie lodz
pozycjonowanie lodz

Posted by Pemysmearesep on Jan. 18, 2013 @ 2:06 am