Of Monsters, Men, and Me

Soledad Prison, aka the Monster Factory.

Editor's Note: California is transferring many prison inmates to jails in their counties of origin, a process known as Realignment that will impact the San Francisco Sheriff's Department. Mayor Ed Lee removed the elected head of that department last week, and the process for determining whether Lee acted appropriately could take months. With that context in mind, we present this inside look at Realignment by Eugene Alexander Day, a third strike inmate at Soledad Prison who will be writing occasional articles about prison life for the Guardian.

A perfect storm is brewing. An unparalleled crisis in corrections is exacerbated by an even worse economy. As a reform-minded inmate buried under a life sentence, it feels like hope is on the horizon. Judicial oversight is the cornerstone.

Due to a murderous and unconstitutional medical department, the Supreme Court implemented a population cap on the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR). December marked the first of four benchmarks. By mid-2013, the prison population must be brought down by 33,000 inmates.

In response, the Legislature passed Prison Realignment (AB 109), which started in October. Once the dust of Realignment settles, state facilities will become the sole domain of real criminals. Serious and violent offenders, called “strikers,” must serve 80 to 85 percent of their sentences. The rest of us are serving life sentences for third strikes, murders, or other violent crimes.

Under Realignment, the counties will maintain custody of those eligible for day-for-day time credits, called “half-timers,” which includes parole violators. For years, experts have been calling for such a shift. Stemming the flow of parole violators and nonviolent, non-serious, and non-sexual offenders, called the three “nons,” is the first real attempt by the state to do the right thing.

By ignoring the evidence for so long, austerity measures and public safety are extremely difficult to reconcile due to judicial oversight. In 2007, Gov. Schwarzenegger convened an expert panel that crafted a road map of rehabilitative recommendations to address overcrowding. The state's other expert panel, the socially irresponsible Legislature, instead chose to double-down on a bad bet.

Under the banner of building more prisons, underscored by sending inmates out-of-state, some of Schwarzenegger's panel's rehabilitative recommendations were codified as unfunded mandates. When the economy took a dive in 2008, the state lawyered up – and got its ass kicked in court.

It took some of the sting off my life sentence when the Supreme Court smashed the CDCR in 2011. Systemic mismanagement corrupted a generation of salvageable prisoners. As someone who lives, breathes, and sleeps the politics of justice, the Legislature didn't simply kick the can down the road – it pushed the state closer to the precipice. State leaders have set a poor example. By failing to follow the evidence in 2007, all 58 counties had Realignment shoved down their throats in 2011.

This lens through which I see the world is depicted as “synchronized drowning” by Attorney General Kamala Harris. For the last 13 years, I've struggled to keep my wits in this sea of despair. Deviants need structured treatment, not more of the same. Shifting the responsibility of tens of thousands of offenders away from CDCR is an idea of brilliant simplicity.

Local law enforcement, prosecutors, and the courts are better suited to solve local problems. These offenders are members of your community. The next time the task force stomps through the ghetto snatching up people of color, they must think about how to house all of these people of imperfection. Good. Most need help, not a jackboot.

To continually be considered part of this particular problem is unacceptable. In her book Monster Factory, Sunny Schwartz opined that everyone from civilians to officers to prisoners “were collaborators in a system that accepted and invested in failure.” No one is exempt. Everyone is to blame. Lives are at stake.

Both Schwartz and Harris describe jails and prisons as crime colleges. I feel like I received tenure in the worst-performing school district in the nation. Untreated criminogenic factors give serious offenders the artistic license to develop unholy subsocietal norms. We sow the seeds of recidivism when low-risk offenders are subjected to our gangbanger, dope-fiend bullshit. Parole violators and the three “nons” are low-hanging fruit: easy to treat and even easier to corrupt.

The counties might hate Realignment, but I hate the fact it took so long. Marking a happy day in this collaborator's miserable life, a whole class of offenders have been diverted away from the Monster Factory. Excellent. Realignment is not some hug-a-thug program. It's basic math. So used to being treated like shit, I will die before I advocate for mollycoddling prisoners. Using offenders as earmarks to maintain an unsustainable status quo is a feeling worse than death. Fix the problem.

My dreams are skewed. In my way of thinking, prisons should become factories that turn monsters into advocates for social justice. Offenders need to learn the difference between pro-social and antisocial behavior, not how to shove dope up their asses or participate in a riot.


of the move to cut costs at the State level, and relocate those costs to municipalities. You can see the same trend in other fields and this has increased under Jerry Brown.

Of course, there was a federal decree to reduce the number in State prisons or, rather, reduce over-crowding. This would either mean building more prisons or sending some prisoners back to county jails. In practice, we are doing both.

State prisons are easily the worst of the three tiers of prisons (federal, state, county) and so it's hardly a surprise that state inmates would be delighted to be relocated. Moreover, the worst prisoners will not be moved, so it's an indicator that you are deemed to be a trustee.

Prisons should become factories for advocates for social justice? Maybe, but i'd settle for law-abiding and productive.

Posted by Guest on Mar. 28, 2012 @ 5:17 pm

Over the past decade inmates have brought on numerous lawsuits to the state. Coleman, Armstrong and Plata to name a few of the big ones. Millions of state tax dollars have been spent to satisfy these lawsuits. Millions spent on medical and psych services, all offered at state prisons for the inmate. Now because of AB109 many inmates who would normally go to prison to get treatment will now go to county jails, which are not equipped nor mandated by the courts to follow these lawsuits. It's only a matter of time before a poor inmate sues the county and breaks the counties bank. The state as whole may be able to recoup from these lawsuits but God help the small county that has to layoff teachers to afford an inmates healthcare.

Posted by Pismolocal on Mar. 29, 2012 @ 5:01 pm

I know the author of this article personaly and I have a very strong understanding of his stance on the issue, and I fully agree with him. Having seen the california prison system turn several of the younger generation into strung out brutes, rather than productive members of the populace, I too feel that it is good to keep the lesser offenders away from those who make a life out of incarceration. (Lifers are not necessarily included in that statement). I always believed that there were inmates and convicts in prison. Inmates just kept their heads down, did their time, and went home with as few mental, emotional, and physical scars as possible. Convicts made prison their life, drugs, lame tattoos, trying to get over on their fellow man, violence, etc. They would also try to indocteranate inmates into the convict lifestyle, hopefully now that will happen less frequently since not as many inmates should wind up celled up with a convict, as the inmates typically had far less serious criminal histories than the convicts do. Realignment is a good thing, though it does come too late for some.

Posted by Zak on Apr. 01, 2012 @ 6:34 pm

Related articles

  • California, from scratch

    A new band from Bay Area punk veterans — with members of Green Day and Jawbreaker — wants to earn your fandom on its own terms

  • "Uncle Leland" suspended from California Senate, with pay for now

  • California prisoners end hunger strike after Bay Area legislators call hearings