School Board to hire new sup't -- quickly

Carlos Garcia is retiring at 60.

San Francisco School Superintendent Carlos Garcia is retiring, which is no surprise -- most school superintendent's rarely stay anywhere for more than five years, and Garcia's contract was up in June. I haven't agreed with him on everything, but overall, he's done a good job -- the schools are better than when he arrived, enrollment is increasing, and there's no more of the imperious attitude and gag orders of the old Ackerman days. The district is on the right track -- although Garcia would be the first to admit that there's a lot more work to be done.

And I have nothing bad to say about his annointed successor, Deputy Superintendent Richard Carranza. He'll probably do a fine job.

But it's a little odd that the board simply handed the job over to Carranza (well, actually they've just agreed to enter contract talks with him, but that's really the same thing) without any sort of public forum, search process or outreach. I mean, there really aren't that many top-rate big-city school superintendents out there, and San Francisco is a tough place for any school chief to work, but still: Do we absolutely know that Carranza is the very best candidate we could ever find? Would it have been worth taking a month or so to check around first?

Again: I believe Carranza will be an excellent successor to Garcia, and if he carries on the same tradition and policies, the schools will be fine. He's been groomed for the job, and won't have to learn the local political scene. Makes perfect sense -- on one level.

But that was awfully quick.

As Board Member Kim-Shree Maufas told me, "It's a transition and things are going well. But where is the public process? Where do our partners -- the unions, the city, corporate partners, the community -- get to weigh in? To take SFUSD to the next level, they need to hear from the community. The board can make that happen."





"They" said that the problem at the SFUSD was Mark Sanchez. The Chronicle hammered on him day in and day out for five years foreshadowing the treatment the Chron would lavish on Chris Daly and Aaron Peskin in the coming years.

But the voters were having none of it. In the 2004 election, progressives took a majority and the problem ended up being Arlene Ackerman. She packed it in, but the contract that the lame duck downtown SFUSD Board lavished on her ensured she'd be taking $375K of our money with her when she resigned a few months later in a huff. Ackerman repeated the performance in Philadelphia recently, socking those poor suckers for almost $1m.

After Mark Sanchez' leadership, the SFUSD has seen 7 years of smooth sailing amidst turbulent seas, the last five under a no-drama superintendent who did not seem to have the narcissistic tendencies that so many high dollar execs have. Happy retirement, Carlos Garcia.

Posted by marcos on Mar. 14, 2012 @ 5:35 pm

Says the replacement is of quality? Then by all means. Because the Bay Guardian is the Guardian of all things citizen.

Just don't loan Kim-Shree Maufas your credit card because you will be SOL.

Posted by matlock on Mar. 14, 2012 @ 9:59 pm


I just found this cool website that shows the best recording studios in new york im just sharing my joy cause I have been looking for one!

its showing the best - new york recording studios for music and sound recording.


Posted by ashleytix on Mar. 14, 2012 @ 10:21 pm

should apply. He doesn't beat children, as far as we know. Only women.

Posted by Chromefields on Mar. 15, 2012 @ 7:30 am

Mark Sanchez?

C'mon, he was an anti-union charter school teacher for years.

As a typical school board member (that is, shopping for a job on the board of supervisors), he ran...and lost.

I hear he is doing a good job as principal of a middle school, however. Good for him. But his influence was minimal on the board

Posted by Guest on Mar. 19, 2012 @ 7:55 am

Related articles

  • Endorsement interviews: Sandra Fewer for School Board

  • The food (truck) fight heats up

  • Cap and frown

    SFUSD considers allowing hats in schools, ending a policy discouraging cultural indicators