Artists still puzzling over destruction of international exchange mural

|
(6)
A spate of graffiti ruined the Alabama and 17th Street mural created by US and Indonesian artists.
PHOTO COLLAGE BY KEVIN MONTGOMERY VIA UPTOWN ALMANAC

In 2003, artists from a San Francisco-Indonesia cultural exchange painted murals on one of the outer walls of Project Artaud, a non-profit art collective in the Mission that provide live-work studios and exhibition space for artists. Within nine years, the expansive mural became a part of the street’s geography — adorning the street like colorful flowers or trees — and was loved by neighbors and passersby alike. But starting last month, tags started to appear on top of the paintings, and within a 24-hour span, the mural faced its tragic and final destruction.

“It feels like a death,” said Jonah Roll, one of the mural’s artists, during a Guardian interview at his home in Project Artaud. During their interview with the Guardian, Roll and Alejandra Rassvetaieff (another artist whose mural was ruined) attempted, to no avail, to understand the reasoning behind the tagger’s recent actions. With so many other empty street walls, why did somebody choose to tag here? Could it have been a personal attack? And is there ever a worthy excuse that justifies destroying someone else’s artwork? 

“If you consider yourself an artist, I don’t think you can just paint on top of another artist’s work,” commented Rassvetaieff. “It’s sad because the murals in the Mission have been here for years, and it’s something that people should respect.”

Scenes from the mural's 2003 creation. Photos via Project Artaud

The mural was created in 2003 as part of a collaboration between San Franciscan artists from the Clarion Alley Mural Project and artists from a public art collective in Indonesia (the project also gave birth to murals at Rainbow Grocery, Clarion Alley, and Le Beau Market in Nob Hill. Entitled "Sama-sama/You're Welcome," the wall was completed after a cultural exchange that sent CAMP artists to Indonesia, and Indonesian artists here to San Francisco. The wall recieved a Best of the Bay award from the Guardian in 2004 for Best Transnational Art Undertaking.

Although there are rumors as to who may have done the taggings — Rassvetaieff noticed the same signature sprayed on her friend’s mural on Market Street — the artists preferred not to disclose names during the interview. “It coincide[d] with a big tagging of work in Clarion Alley that got destroyed around the same time,” said Roll, “they’re doing it for publicity, to spread their name.”

Graffiti is increasingly becoming accepted as a respected art form — and for many good reasons. It serves as an expressive channel for underrepresented people, especially  youth, and is a kind of satisfying slap in the face of corporate advertising that often mars our streetscapes. But tagging on community murals is not a stance against big business. Individual people dedicated hours towards creating these panels of art. 

“I respect the art form of graffiti — there’s a lot of amazing work out there— but it’s sad when something that has value to our community is destroyed,” said Roll. 

The mural in question was a community project that was self-funded by the seven artists. Roll’s section of the mural was a painting dedicated to the passing of his mother and the birth of his new family. Rassvetaieff’s mural, titled “Happiness,” showed a couple embracing under a starry night sky. She said it was meant to celebrate the soul of the human being. 

But Roll's love for her work was no match for the endurance of the taggers, who returned again and again to re-tag the wall. “I couldn’t even go out there in the end for the last tags,” concluded Roll. “I was completely exhausted.” 

Perhaps the most regrettable loss of all was Federico “Pico” Sanchez’s colorful watermelons. The esteemed muralist and art community leader recently passed away in November 2011. 

Street art and graffiti should be working alongside each other — challenging traditional notions of art and working together to promote a sense of expressive cohesiveness in the community. Competition is great, if it fuels growth and demands progress. But artists, hone your craft and create an attention-worthy piece. Real talent tends to get noticed — especially on the streets. 

Weary of covering up tags, Project Artaud members eventually painted the wall a solid shade of green. Bummer.

Guardian photo by Marke B.

Comments

I appreciate the confusion, sadness and frustration shared by the artists. Unfortunately - the assumption that these vandals are artists is part of the problem.

These are Hip Hop graffiti 'throw-ups' and the motivation is to vandalize and gain notoriety, which unfortunately was achieved in a few ways; on the wall, in this article which shows the monikers quite clearly and in social media which is where many vandals post images of their graffiti.

As tempting as it is, I would suggest news stories resist the urge to show the tags in their entirety. It is one of the reasons they hit art work in the first place. Blank walls that get hit with graffiti don't get news coverage the way monuments, murals and trains do. So, that's where fame seeking Hip Hop graffiti vandals put their graffiti.

Sorry your artwork is gone. Don't give up.

Posted by Guest Kristina C on Feb. 01, 2013 @ 3:09 pm

For the past six months or so, mural destruction has been on the upswing here in SF. I've seen it in the Mission, SoMa, Lower Haight, and on Market St. But the first real mural destruction I saw was in LA where freeway murals were gone over by throw ups. Go back in graffiti history and bombing to destroy is part of the game. As street art and murals appear to aid in the gentrification of cities (new condos on Mission St., Wynwood Miami, possibly Baltimore, etc.), there may be a connection between the two. But who knows what those sprayers were thinking when they went over Pico's watermelons (Note that they DID NOT touch the graff pieces on the other side of Artaud). NOT posting photos of the destruction and NOT mentioning the names of the sprayers is the best way to not pass on their infamy. Good call on that.

Posted by Guest on Mar. 26, 2012 @ 6:11 pm

An interesting article to raise awareness about the destruction of Artaud proposed mural on 17th Street Note that the mural in Alabama St. (also wall Artaud) by the artist from Indonesia, who also did a mural at Rainbow supermarket is still intact. While one wall of Artaud, are not eligible, only the long end wall 17, where seven artists painted in 2003 a section was offended by the graffiti artists too (or graffiti).
_-------------------------
Amazing Cheap Logo Design, The Best Logos and Award Winning logo designs with a fantastic team that will work with you till you’re happy or your money back Best logos

Posted by DaudAhmed15 on Mar. 23, 2012 @ 10:58 pm

Seems to have lasted long enough! 9 years is a long time for something to survive. And the stuff that went over it looks pretty old. Note the "07" in one of the dubs!

Why not commission local writers to do something decent? Got to be better than the block of green. And they would be less inclined to go over it!

Posted by Writers Bench on Mar. 21, 2012 @ 2:37 am

Nice writing to bring awareness about the destruction of Project Artaud murals. Note that the mural by artist from Indonesia was not destroyed. Although it is on one of Artaud's walls it still intact. ONLY the 17th street long-fence mural where six artists painted a section in 2003 was insulted by taggers (or Graffiti artists).

Posted by Jada on Mar. 20, 2012 @ 8:43 pm

Nice article to bring awareness about the destruction of Project Artaud mural on 17th Street. Please note that the mural on Alabama St (also an Artaud wall) by the artist from Indonesia who also did a mural at Rainbow grocery still intact. Although is on one of Artaud's walls, it did not get tagged, only the long-fence mural on 17th where seven artists painted a section in 2003 was overly insulted by taggers (or Graffiti artists).

Posted by Jada on Mar. 20, 2012 @ 8:36 pm

Related articles

  • Guerrero gallery bites Zero Graffiti convention

  • Walls of the Internet

    From back alleys to Facebook walls: the street art-tech connection is heating up -- and changing SF's street scene

  • 1AM Gallery's street art app debuts

  • Also from this author

  • Spiritual bump and grind at Purity Ring

  • Live Shots: Rock the Bells at Shoreline Amphitheater

  • 2012 Summer Fairs and Festivals

    Carnaval, Maker Faire, Eat Real, Hardly Strictly Bluegrass, Folsom Street Fair ... Our annual comprehensive guide to outdoor and community affairs