UC Berkeley Student Senate passes divestment measure, but pro-Israel opponents pushing hard for veto
The UC Berkeley Student Senate has passed a bill that calls upon the university to withdraw nearly $12 million in investments from corporations that do business in the Palestinian West Bank, including Caterpillar, Cement Roadstone Holdings, and Hewlett Packard Company. The bill, SB 160, passed at 5am April 18 by a slim 11-9 margin after 10 hours of emotional debate.
When the final vote count was announced, some students cheered and others broke down in tears. While the measure is largely symbolic and unlikely to change university policy, Israel's biggest supporters take such divestment votes very seriously and they were actively trying to influence the outcome of this measure.
The fate of the bill is now in the hands of student President Connor Landgraf, a senior bioengineering major who promised student leaders during his campaign that he would not veto any divestment measure. But now, with the bill sitting on his desk, Landgraf is waffling and supporters of the measure say that may be partially because a pro-Israel group appears to have sponsored his trip to Israel last year.
"During my campaign I did say I wouldn't veto, but now I have different responsibilities," Landgraf told the Bay Guardian. Since Thursday's vote, Landgraf said his phone has been ringing off the hook. "I've received literally hundreds of emails, and I'm under a lot of pressure." [UPDATE 4/24: Landgraf has issued a statement criticizing the bill, but saying that he won't veto it.]
Although ASUC does not exercise any formal control over the school finances, UC student politics have increasingly become a symbolic battleground for a larger debate over the Israel's human rights record.
Student Senator George Kadifa, who authored the bill, is hopeful that other campuses will follow Berkeley's lead: "I'd like to appeal directly to other students governments that have Palestinian communities on campus," he told the Guardian. "If any other students were found to have their houses demolished, or were forced to go through checkpoints to visit their families, would we be silent about that?"
The three companies targeted by Kadifa's bill are involved in providing materials used to construct Israeli settlements, equipping West Bank checkpoints, and manufacturing bulldozers used to demolish Palestinian homes. Daniel Aranki, a Palestinian computer science graduate student, explained that Palestinian students on campus view the university's investments in these companies as a personal affront: "It's my money I pay to the university, and it's invested in human rights violations, against my own family and people that I grew up with," he told the Guardian. The divestment vote at Berkeley is part of a larger push on UC campuses to highlight Israel's human rights record. Over the last year alone, UC Irvine, San Diego, Santa Barbara, and Riverside have all considered various divestment proposals. In response, national pro-Israel organizations are pushing back and directly urging campus leaders to counter the divestment movement.
In 2010, when the ASUC passed a similar divestment measure, the San Francisco-based Israeli console Akiva Tor reached out to then-President Will Smelko and convinced him to exercise his veto. "He said this is not right, this is morally wrong, and he explained to me why it was wrong," Smelko told J Weekly.
Opponents consider divestment a divisive and counterproductive strategy that unfairly singles out Israel for criticism, and divestment on campus has emerged as a major front in the national debate over Israel.
Most Commented On
- Correction - December 11, 2013
- He was from New Orleans - December 11, 2013
- Really? - December 11, 2013
- Oakland is for the little people. - December 11, 2013
- Mr. Jones has made a good point here. - December 11, 2013
- No, SFBG only has the IP address that he or she used. - December 11, 2013
- SF progressives use the word "white" as a slur. - December 11, 2013
- If they have a job, then they can buy healthcare insurance - December 11, 2013
- The best way to help il;legals is to hire them, so they can buy - December 11, 2013
- Good luck taxing something invisible. - December 11, 2013