Hits and misses

Nina Haft and Company and Facing East Dance and Music's intriguing, yet uneven, collaboration

|
(0)
Frances Sedayao and Claire Calalo in this.placed.
PHOTO BY PAK HAN

arts@sfbg.com

DANCE When choreographers Sue Li Jue and Nina Haft found that they shared a common interest in exploring the body's memory — of personal experience, history, origins — they decided to make a work in which their individual choreographies would take turns on the stage. Thus the problematic this.placed was born.

In the past Li Jue has created beautifully designed dance theater pieces that explored her Chinese American heritage from a decidedly contemporary perspective. She did it poignantly, and often with a sense of humor. Haft's interest in Jewish American history has led her to create theatrically pungent works about writers (Gertrude Stein) as well as gangsters (unnamed, though their stories are well known). Additionally, she has quite successfully examined the theatrical potential of specific locations, cemeteries and docks among them.

this.placed is an intriguing, perhaps even fun idea in terms of rethinking presentational formats. It certainly is something that theater artists, dancers, among them, increasingly examine. Yet I don't think this one flew.

For one thing, the 75-minute evening consisted primarily of duets and trios. Though some of them were finely chiseled, more rhythmic variety was needed. Also lacking, I felt, was a sturdier thread that held the individual dances together beyond their place in the lineup. After all, the perspectives by these choreographers are different.

Why, for instance, would a sardonic duet about the wreckage life has inflicted on a woman's face be followed by a trio about happy Chinese adoptees? Misfortune vs. happiness? Or an encounter between two men be preceded by a woman's observations about her mother? Because both vignettes involved memory?

I would like to see this.placed again as two halves of the same program, with perhaps a rethinking of some the dances and some additional material. Conventional as that might be, it might strengthen the focus on the commonality and difference between the two choreographers.

Haft's dynamic interpretations of Britta Austin's gutsy prose certainly warrant additions. The mostly gestural language (for the mouth) of Bite Marks — performed by Jill Randall and Amanda Whitehead — infused a macabre sense of humor on the process of rotting while alive. In Trouble, the mysterious and ever so elegant dancing by Pailing Kao provided a foil to her sturdier "daughter" Sarah Keeney. Flesh, Taste, Fiction started on a note of voyeurism but quickly grew into an obsessively meaty mating à trois. Let You Go's desperate fierce struggle between Carol Kueffer and Lisa Bush left one of them "dead," the other one just about.

Haft's misjudgment was in entrusting one of Austin's texts to a student group. Some of these performers may eventually become dancers. At this point, they belong in a studio setting.

Li Jue's Half the Sky, a pastoral tribute to unwanted Chinese girls who have been adopted abroad, was cloying. It's almost impossible for adult women to suggest the happiness and frolicking quality of childhood. If the choreography was supposed to recall some of the more naïve perspectives of Chinese folk dancing for women, it didn't work.

Related articles

  • Great leaps forward

    Emerging choreographers present new works at SAFEhouse for the Performing Arts' SPF7

  • Meta-morphosis

    Arianne MacBean's dance-theater Big Show Co. scrutinizes the creative process

  • Modern times

    Smith/Wymore Disappearing Acts take on communication in the digital age

  • Also from this author

  • In tune

    Dancers explore fresh rhythms at the Music Moves Festival

  • Great leaps forward

    Emerging choreographers present new works at SAFEhouse for the Performing Arts' SPF7

  • New classics

    Melody Takata brings traditional Japanese dance into the 21st century, plus a benefit for SF dance vet Enrico Labayen