Chiu's challenge

Mayoral candidate wants to demonstrate that a new consensus is possible


Board of Supervisors President David Chiu launched his mayoral campaign Feb. 28 with a pledge to bring San Franciscans of all political stripes together around a common agenda. It's a message that has also been sounded by other mayoral candidates, but one in which Chiu is in a unique position to try to deliver on this year.

"This campaign, at its heart, is going to be how we come together," Chiu told a crowd of hundreds gathered at City Hall for the announcement. Later he told the crowd, "This campaign needs to be a beacon to the rest of the world about who we are as San Franciscans."

Chiu appeared to be reaching out to progressives more than the other mayoral candidates have so far, emphasizing how he doesn't own a car and wants make big improvements to Muni and the bicycle network, valuing "diversity and social justice," calling for "community-based budgeting," and saying that "we have to have a conversation about how we can creatively fund affordable housing."

"We are at our best when we come together for our shared progressive values," Chiu said.

But then he quickly noted that over the past decade, "City Hall has been a bit dysfunctional." That was a time when progressives controlled the Board of Supervisors and there was a downtown-backed mayor, and Chiu decried how the two sides didn't work well together. Yet now, with Chiu as board president and Ed Lee as interim mayor — an appointment Chiu helped engineer — "the tone at City Hall has changed."

Perhaps that's true, but the thorny issues that divide the city and defy simple solutions remain in play: bridging a $380 million budget deficit after years of deep cuts, creating jobs without worsening the city budget picture, controlling employee pension costs, reforming Muni and addressing traffic congestion, bringing cleaner energy sources online, and increasing the affordable housing stock.

These are all issues that President Chiu and Mayor Lee will have to deal with this year if Candidate Chiu is going to be able to credibly claim that the new tone at City Hall can actually translate into policies that work and bring people together.

And there won't be consensus in the community on all of those issues; at some point, Chiu will have to take a side.



All the mayoral candidates argue for coming together around common-sense solutions, a trope that clearly polls well with voters.

Leland Yee welcomed Chiu into the race while emphasizing his own kumbaya message: "My commitment is to run a different kind of campaign for mayor — to work with other candidates to present real choices and options for voters."

Dennis Herrera, whose mayoral campaign announced its endorsement by Sup. Scott Wiener during Chiu's kickoff event, said, "I look forward to working with him toward my goal of making San Francisco a city that works and one that lives up to its great promise"

And Ting told a gathering of his Reset SF group over the weekend, "It's time for San Francisco city government to be as creative and innovative as the rest of San Francisco. And it's going to take all of us to make that a reality."

Even political consultant David Latterman, who usually works with downtown-backed candidates but is working on Chiu's campaign, told us, "I'm just so tired of that left-right divide. I don't think this city is served well by those wars any more."


Wow. I can't believe that MTA Commissioner Cheryl Brinkman, affordable housing and environmental advocate Fei Tsen, progressive Planning Commissioner Christina Olaque, and Supervisor Eric Mar have all joined the Corporate-Military-Industrial-Downtown-Evil Empire Complex. What is Marc S going to do now with himself? Oh yeah - drink with H Brown at Bucks Tavern and pontificate from their comfortable chairs while real progressive activists do the heavy lifting to improve transit, help low-income families, and work in communities of color.

Posted by Getting Shit Done While Marc S Sits On His Ass on Mar. 02, 2011 @ 10:13 am
Posted by marcos on Mar. 02, 2011 @ 6:11 pm

Steven, you've got to be kidding..!

A whole article about Chiu and his courting of progressives without the slightest mention that he just totally betrayed and stabbed in the back, the progressives who got him elected, by his singlehandedly turning over control of the Board and the Mayor's office to a Brown/Pak/Kawa Downtown machine?!

This with the result that at least half of the progressive organizers in this town are now utterly pissed off at Chiu, and are going to stay that way; and will never trust him again as long as he lives.

There is no way in hell that Chiu can be a unifying candidate in the mayor's race having committed that massive act of betrayal against so many key local organizers.

I am honestly, totally astounded, that you made no mention of this obvious and clearly defining central issue of Chiu's candidacy in your article.

Chiu is not a progressive. He is Judas in a suit.

And far too many of us are going to have that foremost in our minds as this campaign season proceeds.

David Chiu is political toast.

Posted by Eric Brooks on Mar. 02, 2011 @ 5:53 pm

"He's willing to take bold moves to make Muni continue to improve," MTA Commissioner and cycling activist Cheryl Brinkman told the gathering.

Except when he's not.


Posted by marcos on Mar. 02, 2011 @ 6:10 pm